Showing posts with label Niagara. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Niagara. Show all posts

Friday, 11 May 2012

How are the Mighty Fallen

over Niagara in a canoe...

Saturday games this time involved two of my more recent acquisitions, both light and attractive "Eurogames": Deadwood and Niagara.

Unlike my first playing of Deadwood (which bills itself as "A Game of Wild West Duels") this time there were actually some gunfights. Though none of them were initiated by me, I did manage to put a couple of cowboys in boot hill.

The game is very simple but took us all a little while to grasp. It takes place in a growing town and one has to lay and exploit various building tiles as the railroad heads towards town to bring prosperity to Deadwood.



The gameplay can be summed up as place or remove cowboys but this is complicated by the variable effects of taking over (annexing in the words of the rulebook) different buildings. It was this aspect and learning the meaning of the iconography used on the building tiles that took a little while to master.

In the end my skilful gun-play (or lucky die rolls) did not result in my being king of Deadwood and while I made the move that ended the game it turned out that I was only the kingmaker who crowned Paultro in his first victory of the evening.

Deadwood not being a big game (though perhaps too meaty to be described as a filler) we had plenty of time for a game of Niagara. This was new to the Goldstone Gamers but they picked it up quickly. Perhaps more than can be said of me as I forgot that I wasn't my customary blue and carefully made plans based on that erroneous assumption which when used on my actual green canoes resulted in disaster.






Indeed, there was a great deal of over-the-falls action in this game but then that is half the fun and what the "moving river" design of the game is all about. It was a lot of fun and I still managed a respectable haul of gems which would have resulted in a win on the next turn if it hadn't been for Paultro skilfully obtaining one of each type of gem and winning again.



Canoes and Comuni


Four gamers turned up this week and brought with them Comuni again. I was seething with rage about something entirely unrelated and didn't give it my full attention for a while but it is a game I like and I settled down to play.

This time I did not intend to repeat my acquisition of loads of penalty points and changed strategy entirely, building little and trailing behind in the points. I found it easy to deal with the battles, and indeed "overpaid" the black cubes each time, even picking up a couple of the early bonuses.


 As far as the overall score was concerned though, this stategy kept me in such a distant last that I remained there. On the plus side I had no penalties at all, on the minus side I was a distant last in by far my worst ever playing of the game. I definitely played it better when I didn't know it well, the more I think about what I'm doing the worse I get. To turn last week's conclusion on its head, I think perhaps I should never play this game again!



As we finished in good time we had time for a filler and,  after another round of teas etc., my opponents emerged from my games collection with Niagara. This is very light but can be a lot of fun..as it proved to be on this occasion. I managed to get a good collection of the easier to reach gems quite quickly and was on the verge of a seven gem win but Crabro had been more selective and pipped me to the post with his collection of one each of the five colours. I finished, or would have, on the same move but Crabro was before me in the playing order that turn. Very kindly he said that he regarded it as a draw for the two old men. I say he won fair and square...but I'll happily take the draw offered to take the taste of defeat away after the Comuni disaster.

Monday, 12 March 2012

Year of the Disappointing Beaver?

This week's Tuesday games were "In the Year of the Dragon" and "Niagara" both of which were from the second-hand table at the previous Saturday's game day.

We first set out the very attractive "pick-up-and-deliver" game Niagara, in which one collects gems placing them in small wooden canoes and attempts to return them up-river to safety. The movement is by sets of cards but the game has an interesting mechanism to simulate the flow of the river, which can result in the canoes (and contents) vanishing over the falls. The game board has been cunningly designed to lay across the two halves of the box in order to create an actual drop.

After an initial try which, if nothing else, taught me the value of getting both canoes in the river as soon as possible (i.e. Crabro won fairly easily) we played again, this time adding in the mini-expansion "Diamond Joe" and the more complex "The Spirits of Niagara" expansion this time I think I actually won, though no-one was more surprised than me to discover that as I seemed to spend a substantial part of the game just trying to survive rather than gaining gems.

 The Diamond Joe expansion, although made more attractive by coming in a little draw-string bag, is basically just a neutral coloured canoe which moves up and down the river and offers trading possibilities and another potential source of a gem.

The Spirits expansion offers several variations. It includes double canoes, three extra cards per player (a 7, a 1/2/3 choice card and a lasso which enables a canoe to temporarily leave the river) a cardboard set of Elk antlers which can add movement points the player controlling them and a little wooden beaver. There are also enough cards and canoes to add a sixth player. 



The beaver proved to be rather disappointing. Despite being a nice little miniature, all it does is add the possibility of resetting the weather once in a while (in fact it didn't happen at all in our game). I was rather hoping that it would do something much more interesting: like gnaw a hole in the bottom of a canoe for example.




The final part of the expansions consists of a sticker, representing a whirlpool, which sticks on one of the transparent discs which allow for the river movement. The whirlpool is an obstacle to player canoes and Joe, requiring extra movement allowance to pass and spitting one out downstream if landed on.





Our second game was another by Stefan Feld, designer of Notre Dame and Macao both of which we like. In the Year of the Dragon proved to be exactly as we had heard it described: Much simpler to play than it at first looked from the rules but much more difficult to play well. The reason is that it is beautifully balanced and always gives you several options. You feel there are several things you would like to do but you can only do one. Will you make the right choice? ...Well no, not if you're me anyway. You need to go for VPs but at the same time you need to make sure your palaces and men are protected from the coming events (famine, contagion etc)

It's one of those games that I really enjoy even though I'm not winning and one I can imagine always being happy to play. I can't remember the scores (probably a mercy) but I do remember I had a lot of fun playing both these games.

A really good Tuesday games day in my book.